Fluorescent lamps
- An excellent general luminaire for indoor use but not ideal for outdoor areas
- Various shapes, sizes, and efficacies
- High efficacy (>100 lm/W)
- Wide colour range (Ra > 90)
- The need for an electronic ballast for control (control range 1–100%)
- A long useful life
Compact fluorescent lamps (energy-saving lamps)
- A high level of illumination for a small amount of energy
- A good light source for general lighting and for spaces that require a high level of illumination
- A light source that doesn’t withstand being turned on and off frequently
- Lighting that comes into its own in outdoor luminaires (not all models; also, luminaire protection must be taken into account)
- Efficacy of 50–80 lm/W
- Full brightness only after a warm-up period
- A solution that usually is not dimmable
Halogen lamps
- Use for spotlighting and outdoor lighting
- Easy control (with several possible control methods and a control range of 1–100%)
- Good colour rendering
- Good light optics
- Small luminaires
- Availability with several lamp bases (GU10, PARxx, and bi-pin)
- Surface temperatures possibly reaching high levels
- In control, a need for compatibility between the transformer and controller
- A high illuminance value (glare) of the filament
Metal-halide lamps
- Suitability for high spaces and outdoor lighting
- High efficacy, 75–120 lm/W
- Good light optics
- Good colour rendering (Ra up to 90)
- A long useful life
- A long warm-up period
- Need for a starter
- Dimming that affects the light colour
- Dimmability for only the non-compensated lamps (control range 50–100%)
- A decreased service life when dimming is used (not recommended)
- The need for lamps to be turned on at full efficacy (once they have been on for 10 minutes, they can be dimmed in stages)
High-pressure sodium lamps
- Suitability for road and street lighting
- White SON also for indoor lighting
- Utility in illuminating yellow, red, and brown tones
- Need for a starter
- High efficacy, 60–150 lm/W
- A long useful life
- High luminous flux values
- Restricted colour rendering
- Control not recommended (control range 50–100%, for short periods 30%)
- Dimmability for only the non-compensated lamps (dimming shortens the service life)
- The need for lamps to be turned on at full efficacy (once they have been on for 10 minutes, they can be dimmed in stages)
- A long warm-up period
Low-pressure sodium lamps
- Road and street lighting as the most common application
- High efficacy, up to 200 lm/W
- Need for a starter
- Poor colour rendering properties
- A short service life
- Lack of dimmability
- A type that is being replaced with high-pressure sodium lights on motorways and in some other applications
High-pressure mercury lamps
- Suitability for outdoor lighting in parks
- No need for a starter
- Poor efficacy values (40–60 lm/W)
- Control not recommended (control range 50–100%)
- The need for lamps to be turned on at full efficacy (once they have been on for 10 minutes, they can be dimmed in stages)
- A solution that was withdrawn from the market by 2015 because of its low efficacy (under the Ecodesign Directive)
LED
- A long service life, up to 50,000 hours
- Low energy consumption
- High efficacy, 75–113 lm/W (and still improving)
- Easy control and dimming (note: conventional controllers can be used)
- No changes in service life with the number of times the lamp is turned on
- Still a relatively expensive solution
- Sensitivity to high temperatures (this affects the service life and reduces luminous flux)
- The possibility of glare, since this is a small and bright source of light
Induction lamps
- Suitability for outdoor lighting and high spaces
- Good efficacy, up to 70 lm/W
- A long service life, up to 100,000 hours
- No changes in service life with the number of times the lamp is turned on
Light source
|
Efficacy (lm/W)
|
Corresponding colour temperature (K)
|
Colour rendering index Ra
|
Service life (h)
|
Dimmability
|
Fluorescent lamp
|
70 -100
|
2,700–13,000
|
70 - 90
|
approx. 15,000
|
yes
|
Compact fluorescent lamp
|
50 - 80
|
2,700–6,000
|
85
|
approx. 10,000
|
yes
|
High-pressure mercury lamp
|
40 - 60
|
3,000–4,500
|
40 - 70
|
approx. 24,000
|
yes
|
Low-pressure sodium lamp
|
up to 200
|
2,700–3,500
|
0
|
approx. 18,000
|
no
|
High-pressure sodium lamp
|
60 - 150
|
2,000–2,600
|
20 - 85
|
approx. 20,000
|
yes
|
Metal-halide lamp
|
75 - 120
|
3,000–6,500
|
60 - 95
|
approx. 10,000
|
yes
|
Halogen lamp
|
approx. 20
|
2,700–5,000
|
100
|
approx. 2,000
|
yes
|
LED
|
75
|
3,000–6,500
|
>90
|
up to 50,000
|
yes
|